Review: Kids' flick 'Escape from Planet Earth' mediocre, at best

'Escape from Planet Earth'

"Escape from Planet Earth"

Astronaut Scorch Supernova is a national hero to the blue alien population. A master of daring rescues, Scorch pulls off astonishing feats with the quiet ...

Rating: PG for action and some mild rude humor

Length: 89 minutes

Released: February 15, 2013 Nationwide

Cast: Brendan Fraser, Rob Corddry, Ricky Gervais, Jonathan Morgan Heit, Jessica Alba

Director: Callan Brunker

Writer: Callan Brunker, Bob Barlen

More info and showtimes »

If you're a parent, chances are you've seen worse animated films than "Escape from Planet Earth." Mostly, one might add, from the same studio that released this one.

But "Earth" is something of a giant — OK, mini-giant — leap forward for The Weinstein Co. It's not much funnier than most of their earlier fare. But at least it's not as ugly as "Hoodwinked," "Doogal" and the rest.

Reaching that "Space Chimps"/"Planet 51" level of good-looking mediocrity is an achievement. Pop the champagne!

The blue aliens of Baab have this Buzz Lightyear-style hero, "Scorch," a space rescuer-hero whose adventures are covered by live video feed from wherever in the universe he is sent. Scorch is all bravado and swagger and catch-phrase.

"Scorch me, baby!"

He's a regular rock star - and a bit of a dope. He is voiced by Brendan Fraser.

Dopey Scorch always has his mild-mannered tech-nerd brother Gary (Rob Corddry) back at Mission Control, pulling his blue biscuits out of the fire. Until that day that the egotistical Scorch "fires" Gary.

"I QUIT."

Same diff. This happens just as Scorch leaves on a mission to "The Dark Planet," the place where aliens — even those who "come in peace" — disappear. Which is what Scorch does, right in front of the 7-Eleven on the outskirts of Area 51. Yes, the "Dark Planet" is our own — Earth.

Gary's gung-ho son and ex-test pilot wife (Sarah Jessica Parker) shame him into attempting a rescue. Meanwhile, Scorch is discovering that the team of screenwriters has plagiarized "Monsters vs. Aliens" and that Area 51 is a vast holding pen where Craig Robinson, Jane Lynch (naturally) and George Lopez voice other imprisoned aliens, and William Shatner is the creepy general in charge.

The gags that work in this thing are mostly visual. Ricky Gervais voices a computer who uses old black and white movie and news footage to show the perils of "The Dark Planet" — "The only known world where evolution is taking place in reverse."

Gervais does some riffing, and since Stephen Fry's name appears on the long list of writing credits, perhaps he helped the lad out.

The animation is what sells "Escape from Planet Earth," rich, textured surfaces — check out the fishnet webbing on Scorch's space suit, the paint worn off the hardware and the perfectly rendered 7-Eleven, where even the Slurpee (product placement in a cartoon?) shimmers like the real thing.

It's not worth paying 3D prices — 3D is for suckers, especially when it comes to kids' animation.

Years in development, re-written to death according to the lawsuit some of those involved filed against the Weinsteins, and not funny, to boot — not a ringing endorsement. But unlike say, "Doogal" or "Hoodwinked 2," at least you won't want to gouge your eyes out after this one.

---

'ESCAPE FROM PLANET EARTH'

2 stars out of 4/grade C

MPAA Rating: PG for action and some mild rude humor

Cast: The voices of Brendan Fraser, Sarah Jessica Parker, Rob Corddry, William Shatner, George Lopez

Credits: Directed by Cal Brunker. A Kaleidoscope TWC release.

Running time: 1:32

Distributed by MCT Information Services

© 2013 Knoxville.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Comments » 0

Be the first to post a comment!

Want to participate in the conversation? Become a subscriber today. Subscribers can read and comment on any story, anytime. Non-subscribers will only be able to view comments on select stories.

Already activated? Login